Article Text

PDF
Fifteen-minute consultation: Diabulimia and disordered eating in childhood diabetes
  1. Toby Candler1,
  2. Rhian Murphy2,
  3. Aisling Pigott3,4,
  4. John W Gregory1,5
  1. 1 Department of Child Health, University Hospital of Wales, Cardiff, UK
  2. 2 Department of Clinical Psychology, University Hospital of Wales, Cardiff, UK
  3. 3 Department of Nutrition and Dietetics, University Hospital of Wales, Cardiff, UK
  4. 4 Cardiff School of Health Sciences, Cardiff Metropolitan University, Cardiff, UK
  5. 5 Division of Population Medicine, School of Medicine, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK
  1. Correspondence to Dr Toby Candler, Department of Child Health, University Hospital of Wales, Heath Park, Cardiff CF14 4XW, UK; toby.candler{at}gmail.com

Abstract

Type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1DM) is a common chronic disease in children and young people. Living with diabetes can pose many challenges both medical and psychological. Disordered eating behaviours, intentional insulin omission and recognised eating disorders are common among young people with diabetes and are associated with increased risk of short-term and long-term complications and death. Recognition of these behaviours is important to ensure that relevant support is provided. Joint working between diabetes and mental health teams has challenges but is essential to ensure all needs are met during treatment and recovery.

  • diabetes
  • adolescent health
  • child psychology
  • evidence based medicine
  • general paediatrics

Statistics from Altmetric.com

The problem

Living with diabetes, like many other chronic illnesses, can place a significant burden on the child and their family. Accepting that diabetes is lifelong and has potential to disrupt activities of childhood can pose psychological difficulties for young people and their families. Diabetes is associated, to varying degrees, with higher rates of a range of psychological difficulties including eating disorders1 which has led the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence in the UK (NICE) to recommend that a Clinical Psychologist forms part of the diabetes multidisciplinary team,2 a requirement for receipt of the Best Practice Tariff (a system in England to financially incentivise the delivery of high quality care for children with diabetes by units demonstrating evidence of agreed care criteria).

A number of studies have identified high rates of disordered eating behaviours, issues with body image and intentional manipulation of insulin for weight loss among young people with diabetes.3 4 A recent meta-analysis5 showed a higher prevalence of disordered eating problems (39.3% vs 32.5%) and eating disorders (7.0% vs 2.8%) in adolescents with type 1 diabetes mellitus (T1DM) compared with peers without T1DM. ‘Diabulimia’ is an increasingly used term to describe intentional insulin omission to induce weight loss (see box 1). Disordered eating behaviours are thought to be more common among girls than boys, and more frequently identified in adolescents.6 Disordered eating is associated with higher HbA1c (glycated haemoglobin) and increased risk of microvascular complications, particularly retinopathy.7 Insulin restriction leads to increased risks of ketoacidosis and long-term complications including retinopathy, nephropathy, vascular disorders and premature death.8 Goebel-Fabbri and colleagues8 reported more than three times the relative risk of death among those who intentionally restrict insulin, with a mean age of death of 44 years compared with 58 years in those who did not report intentional insulin restriction.

Box 1

Key definitions

Eating disorders

The term ‘eating disorders’ encompasses anorexia nervosa (AN), bulimia nervosa (BN) and atypical eating disorders or eating disorder not otherwise specified(EDNOS). The two classification systems for eating disorders (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th Edition, Text Revision (DSM IV TR) and International Classification of Diseases-10 (ICD-10)) distinguish between AN (primarily characterised by weight loss) and BN (primarily characterised by bingeing and purging).

Disordered eating behaviours

Maladaptive eating behaviours including fasting and dieting; binge eating; self-induced vomiting; the abuse of laxatives, diet pills and other medications though the behaviour and psychopathology does not reach threshold for a diagnosis of an eating disorder as per DSM IV TR and ICD-10.

Diabulimia

An increasingly used term to describe intentional insulin omission or manipulation to induce weight loss.

The management of T1DM includes a focus on healthy eating, carbohydrate counting and insulin timing. Young people are regularly weighed and their weight is openly discussed with often a noticeable increase in weight after diagnosis. This can lead to an overfocus on body weight and shape with adverse implications for blood glucose control. Living with T1DM is associated with higher anxiety and depression1 2 which again can predispose to maladaptive eating behaviours. Sadness and struggles accepting the diagnosis can also contribute to these difficulties.

A framework for understanding the processes that lead to  the development and maintenance of an eating disorder in children and young people with diabetes is shown in figure 1.

Figure 1

Development and maintenance of eating disorders in T1DM (adapted from Fairburn20).

THE CASE

This growth chart (figure 2) illustrates a common presentation in paediatric diabetes clinics. Focus is needed in the consultation to establish the underlying cause of the poor glycaemic control and weight loss which will shape subsequent management.

Figure 2

The case.  Imagine a 15-year-old girl with T1DM attends Diabetes Clinic with a high HbA1c. She was diagnosed 2.5 years ago (first arrow), and continues multiple daily insulin injections with carbohydrate counting. Before she comes into the clinic room with her family, the growth chart is reviewed and it shows a weight loss of 6 kg over the last 3 months (second arrow). The girl’s mother speaks to her Paediatric Diabetes Specialist Nurse and reports she is concerned about her daughter’s low mood and increased focus on the appearance of her body.

The consultation

It is important to guide history taking and examination to exclude organic causes of weight loss including hyperthyroidism and coeliac disease as well as other systemic illnesses. An assessment of the patient’s current insulin regime together with a review of serial blood glucose measurements may suggest a deficiency of prescribed insulin.

There are many psychosocial issues that impact on glycaemic control. At times, young people struggle to engage with their diabetes, leading to a reluctance to adhere to their insulin regime or monitoring of blood glucose. There are many reasons for this and it is important to take a wider psychosocial history (eg, exploring home, school, friendship, activities, risk taking behaviours) to explore potential risks and resilience.

Assessment of disordered eating and diabulimia

Identifying diabulimia and disordered eating can be difficult in practice. Young people are often reluctant to disclose a history of disordered eating. By their very nature, eating disorders are secretive and young people may feel ashamed of their struggle.9 It can be very difficult to get them to talk about or recognise that they have a problem. It is important to involve other members of the multidisciplinary team whose expertise and relationship with the young person may elucidate crucial information that points towards a diagnosis of intentional insulin omission and/or disordered eating behaviours. An empathetic, accepting, non-blaming and curious stance helps enable honesty in young people. The context in which consultations take place (ie, privacy, presence of parents, known or unknown staff members) should be carefully considered. Strong links with schools facilitates sharing of concerns10 regarding eating behaviours and helps to build a thorough understanding.

The clinical features suggestive of disordered eating and diabulimia are shown in box 2. Rising HbA1c and/or changing weight may be the only initial sign of concern.

Box 2

Clinical features of diabulimia and disordered eating in diabetes

  • Change in eating habits

  • Low mood, poor self-esteem

  • Distorted body image

  • Weight loss or weight gain

  • Purging behaviours (vomiting, excessive exercise, use of laxatives)

  • Binge eating behaviours

  • Hoarding food

  • Worsening glycaemic and metabolic control (rise in HbA1c, hyperglycaemia and hypoglycaemia)

  • Missed or cancelled appointments

  • Change in school attendance

  • Admission for diabetic ketoacidosis

  • Secretive behaviour

  • Evidence of accessing internet sites which focus on weight loss

Many centres use screening questionnaires to identify mood disturbances and psychological difficulties in children and young people with diabetes, for example, Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire.11 Screening tools used for detection of eating disorders in young people with diabetes often have developed from tools used in the general population and include mSCOFF (modified SCOFF eating disorder questionnaire),12 mEDI (modified Eating Disorder Inventory)13 and DEPS (Diabetes Eating Problem Survey).14 mSCOFF (see box 3) and DEPS offer a concise, self-report survey to detect disordered eating behaviours in young people with diabetes and can be used in clinical settings to identify these behaviours.

Box 3

Modified SCOFF questionnaire

  1. Do you make yourself Sick because you feel uncomfortably full?

  2. Do you worry you have lost Control over how much you eat?

  3. Have you recently lost >14 lbs (One stone) in a 3-month period?

  4. Do you believe yourself to be Fat when others say you are too thin?

  5. Do you ever take less Insulin than you should?

Positive score of 2 or more is suggestive of an eating disorder

Management

Prevention

There are several risk factors associated with developing disordered eating or diabulimia (box 4). Specific targeting of at-risk children with diabetes may prove advantageous. There is evidence from other areas of high eating disorder prevalence (eg, weight-specific sports) that prevention programmes focused on positive body image and antirestrictive behaviours significantly reduce the incidence of eating disorder development.15

Box 4

Risk factors for development of disordered eating and diabulimia

  • Female gender

  • Higher body mass index pre diagnosis

  • Low self-esteem or history of depression

  • Body dissatisfaction

  • Diabetes diagnosis between 7 and 18 years

  • Family history of dieting or eating disorders

Multidisciplinary approach

  • Early intervention is essential in the management of any eating disorder, but particularly in those with T1DM.

  • A multidisciplinary approach between the diabetes team, child and adolescent mental health teams and other agencies (eg, school, youth worker) is essential with agreement needed for individual treatment plans. Close communication and support between teams is important as adolescent mental health teams may have little experience of managing diabetes nor paediatric diabetes teams of eating disorders.

Insulin management and medical approach

  • The associated weight gain with insulin treatment may reinforce the perceived benefits of insulin restriction as an effective weight loss tool.

  • There may need to be a relaxation of glycaemic targets to try and achieve small incremental goals with regard to their disordered eating and prevent rapid weight gain which can be counterproductive to their overall care.

  • The timing of insulin (usually advised premeal) may have to be delayed to prevent hypoglycaemia if the young person does not complete meals.

  • Insulin regimes may be revised accordingly with some evidence that pump therapy (with lower insulin requirements which minimises weight gain) leads to reduced disordered eating behaviours16 and better HbA1c in those with T1DM and eating disorders.17

  • Medical or parental supervision of meal times is often needed.

  • The importance of appropriate insulin dosing to restore weight and nutritional status of the individual may not always be appreciated by mental health services, though is important for diabetes care.

Dietetic approach

  • Dietetic treatment should encourage flexible and non-restrictive approaches to eating, while still focusing on regular meal patterns and carbohydrate counting.

  • Encouraging intuitive and flexible approaches to food by the young person and their family should underpin dietetic treatment recommendations.

  • Weighing all sources of carbohydrate may need to be relaxed, and estimation encouraged.

  • A whole diet approach towards normalisation and stabilisation of eating patterns is recommended.

  • Concurrent stabilising of meal patterns (combined with insulin adherence) is necessary to promote glycaemic control and restore weight changes, decision making and reduce food anxieties.

  • It is important to appreciate concerns over body shape and weight, particularly when re-engaging with insulin treatment.

Psychological approach

  • Psychological therapy for eating disorders may take various forms depending on the individual and condition, for example, Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) and family therapy.

  • It is important that the clinical psychologists between both teams work together to ensure that both the eating disorder and impact of diabetes on daily living are understood and discussed. This helps to ensure that interventions are effective, and a cohesive message is given across both teams.

NICE guidance2 advises awareness of diabetic complications which may prevent recovery (eg, gastroparesis) and encourages joint working with mental health practitioners. The details of these guidelines are not explicit and the practicalities of application are challenging (see table 1). The availability of diabetes specific inpatient eating disorder support is likely not to be available. Therefore, regular reviews and discussions between diabetes and mental health teams are crucial. When working with a young person with an eating disorder, ‘splitting’ is common,10 for example where one party is seen as ‘good’ and the other ‘bad’. These processes are unconscious and relate to the inner conflicts and overwhelming emotions the young person is facing. This can cause problems within and between teams, meaning that efforts to maintain joint working, peer education and effective communication are especially important.

Table 1

National guidelines of eating disorders and diabetes care.  

Conclusions

Identifying disordered eating behaviours, eating disorders and diabulimia can be difficult in practice. Raising awareness among the multidisciplinary team is crucial to ensure these problems are considered in consultations. Screening tools can be effective and should be used when clinically suspected and considered as part of annual diabetes review. The management of comorbid eating disorders and diabetes is challenging and conventional approaches to diabetes care may need to be adapted to fit the individual. Effective joint working with mental health teams forms a key part of treatment and recovery with early liaison encouraged.

Test your knowledge

  1. Those children and young people with diabetes at higher risk of developing disordered eating/diabulimia include

    1. Boys

    2. Adolescents

    3. A family history of dieting or eating disorders

    4. Diagnosed with diabetes between 7-18 years

    5. Higher BMI pre diabetes diagnosis

  2. Signs or symptoms of disordered eating/diabulimia include

    1. High HbA1c

    2. Low mood

    3. Weight change

    4. Diabetic ketoacidosis

    5. Secretive behaviour

  3. Screening tools used to identify disordered eating/diabulimia include

    1. DEPS

    2. mEDI

    3. mSCOFF

    4. Skills and Difficulties Questionnaire

    5. Conners’ questionnaire

  4. Management of disordered eating/diabulimia may include

    1. Diabetes multidisciplinary team – doctors, dietitians, clinical psychologist and paediatric diabetes nurse specialist

    2. Youth worker

    3. Child and adolescent mental health teams (CAMHS) only if the child or young person reaches threshold for eating disorder (eg, anorexia nervosa)

    4. Inpatient eating disorder facility

    5. Liaison with CAMHS team

Answers are at the end of the references.

Answers to the quiz

(1) b, c, d, e; (2) a, b, c, d, e; (3) a, b, c; (4) a, b, d, e.

Acknowledgments

TC devised the idea for the article and led the writing of the manuscript. RM and AP helped contribute to the writing and revision of the article. JG helped plan the article, supervised the project and contributed to editing the manuscript.

References

View Abstract

Footnotes

  • Competing interests None declared.

  • Provenance and peer review Commissioned; externally peer reviewed.

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.